skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Cant wait until the buffet is back...will be my first placeto go....love it.!
Marion Thurow via google.com - Nov 22, 2020
My aunt and I had a really bad experience one night with terrible food... Then when we called to complain we talked to a woman named Tammy... She helped us tremendously and had our order completely remade and it was absolutely perfect... Anyway... Now we always ask for her and she's so nice that she takes our order and makes sure eve ... read more
Rob K via google.com - Nov 15, 2020
Great pizza quick curbside pickup.
Dan Susnik via google.com - Nov 14, 2020
Most amazing garlic bread on the planet! Pizzas are great as is the lasagna and chicken parm! Highest grades. We live in Madison and drive over to eat here.
Scott Dicks via google.com - Nov 13, 2020
The pizza was suburb. It's thin crust crunchy, not a big wad of dough around the edge. The added toppings were generous and fresh. The entire pizza tasted great and is the reason I always return whenever I am hungry and close by. My wife says the same thing about there Gluten free pizzas too!
Don Pridemore via google.com - Nov 9, 2020
Was ahhhmazing ... read more
Connie Plunkett via google.com - Nov 7, 2020
so delicious!! Best garlic bread in the world!!
so delicious!! Best garlic bread in the world!!
Ron Kundinger Sr. via facebook.com - Nov 6, 2020
Great old school atmosphere. Incredible garlic bread. Great pizza and appetizers. Servers are so nice. Socially distanced seating. We felt very comfortable.
ccsquared69 via google.com - Oct 30, 2020
Enjoyed very much ... read more
brian santner via google.com - Oct 24, 2020
Great food! The garlic bread is the best I ever had!
Jean Betancourt via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Split a large House Salad and the garlic bread and loved every bite! The garlic bread was dripping with butter, yum!
Lori Nashban via google.com - Oct 11, 2020
The best garlic bread on the planet!
Robert Theurer via google.com - Oct 8, 2020
Awesome food!
Jennifer Biefeld via google.com - Oct 6, 2020
Great food and pizza ... read more
David Peltier via google.com - Oct 3, 2020
I’ve had the lasagna, the spaghetti, the pizza and their garlic bread each many times over - mmmmm. And their salad. mmmmm. Is there ANYTHING this kitchen aint the best at?!!
Ken Mason via google.com - Oct 3, 2020
Excellent pizza the best garlic bread in town hands down ... read more
Dick Beste via google.com - Sep 26, 2020
Quick service for pickup, very fresh salad and great tasting pizza (even the meatless option!) Price maybe worth splitting worth with friends, but overall stands up to the food!
Richard Sauer via google.com - Sep 26, 2020
A classic in Milwaukee! Old school Milwaukee pizza. Cracker thin crust topped with a rich tomato sauce add whatever toppings you want. Be careful, don't add too many toppings though or else you risk loosing the magic of the crust. If you say Mama Mia's in front of my husband you'll see his face soften and his eyes light up. In the 70 ... read more
Kathryn Goral via google.com - Sep 19, 2020
Garlic bread!
Tim Hedberg via google.com - Sep 19, 2020
Best lasagna ever ... read more
David Brown via google.com - Sep 17, 2020
The best garlic bread!!! Good service good food ... read more
chad c via google.com - Sep 16, 2020
Had a wonderful dinner with family enjoying delicious food. And Josh our waiter was awesome. Give t
Had a wonderful dinner with family enjoying delicious food. And Josh our waiter was awesome. Give that man a raise 😉 ... read more
Sarah Mae via facebook.com - Sep 5, 2020
Fantastic food!
Wil Gibb via google.com - Sep 4, 2020
Excellent Italian food and awesome service and staff
Excellent Italian food and awesome service and staff ... read more
Kevin Olson via facebook.com - Sep 3, 2020
Really good. Very nice size portions. Only thing that could use improvement is not a very big selection on menu, other than that no complaints. We will return.
Billy Green via google.com - Aug 31, 2020
All good, will go back.
Tom Benvenuto via google.com - Aug 23, 2020
Breadsticks... Pizza is great. Other Italian dishes are tasty. The bread makes this place. If you don't have it you didnt visit properly.
Jeff Fulcer via google.com - Aug 23, 2020
No words .... The food was incredible! I would drive from Michigan JUST for the bread! Indescribable!
Aron Chubb via google.com - Aug 16, 2020
This is freaky yummy Lasagna and Garlic bread. Service is not the quickest but GOOD takes a second to make. 😉👍💪 ... read more
Eric D. Rusch via google.com - Aug 15, 2020
Great food. Fast friendly service.
Carole Neuok via google.com - Aug 14, 2020
Been a family favorite for decades and never dissapoints. Great food.
mark andersen via google.com - Aug 13, 2020
So so- should of gotten the garlic bread with mozz
So so- should of gotten the garlic bread with mozz ... read more
Dan Jay Larink via facebook.com - Aug 7, 2020
The food is excellent for the price, the only problem is figuring out how to get into their parking lot.
Bill Beard via google.com - Aug 4, 2020
We came in tonight for the first time. The food was fantastic, and our server was so nice/understan
We came in tonight for the first time. The food was fantastic, and our server was so nice/understanding (our child was being relentless.) I didn't catch her name, but if you read this, thank you so much for going out of your way to accommodate us. We almost took it to go out of embarrassment because we didn't want to distract anyone ... read more
Roy Petersen via facebook.com - Jul 24, 2020
One of the better pizzas in town ... read more
Nick Podushak via google.com - Jul 20, 2020
The buffet is absolutely delicious! I miss it every single day!
Tyler Fritz via google.com - Jul 8, 2020
Beer batter cod was great. So was curb side service.
Susan McGuff via google.com - Jun 6, 2020
Good stuff ... read more
Andrew Schlei via google.com - Jun 1, 2020
After traveling all over the US, hands down, Mama Mia's has the most delicious garlic bread and pizza!
Kathy Braun via google.com - May 29, 2020
Have been coming here for years and are never disappointed! The pizzas are fantastic, nice thin crispy crust. THe lasagna is decadent. They are famous for their garlic bread - so crispy and buttery! The lunch buffet is a great deal!
Katelyn Heimbruch via google.com - May 20, 2020
Perhaps the best lasagna in town!
Liko Chico via google.com - May 19, 2020
Delicious! and awesome garlic bread!
Delicious! and awesome garlic bread!
Joe Vento via facebook.com - Apr 5, 2020
Thank you for making your curb side pick up so easy and efficient! Our order was ready on time and
Thank you for making your curb side pick up so easy and efficient! Our order was ready on time and the employee who brought it out was super sweet! The food was delicious especially my favorite item, the garlic bread! Keep up the great work!!!
Janis Medek via facebook.com - Apr 3, 2020
Best Italian I've ever had!
SCOTT ZACHER via google.com - Mar 17, 2020
As always their garlic bread was simply amazing! And the young guy that helped me at the pickup window was very friendly and happy and couldn't do enough for me. I wish I knew his name.
kathy bartz via google.com - Mar 12, 2020
Another Milwaukee area institution! A must try for visitors! I recommend the lunch buffet you get to try so much of the menu for an amazing price! Servers are friendly and it's a real family environment. Stop in, you will love it!
Mike Lopez via google.com - Mar 10, 2020
Everything is good!!!! So easy on the garlic bread and salad!!!
Lane Lindstrom via google.com - Mar 9, 2020
Incredible Pizza and fantastic Garlic Bread!!! So good we drive from Mayville.
Bill Fahringer via google.com - Mar 8, 2020
Love the pizza ... read more
Slewfoot Signs via google.com - Mar 7, 2020
The garlic bread is unbelievably good. Great pizza and other dishes. Generous portions and reasonable prices along with great service.
doug plein via google.com - Mar 7, 2020
Garlic bread love it ... read more
Mike Fulwiler via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
Great pizza and cheese garlic bread!! Small seating area but great food, get there early!!
Lisa Willis via google.com - Mar 2, 2020
A Milwaukee institution for a reason! The food is consistently good. The garlic bread (err brick?) is best with a little salt added, and you can't go wrong with the house salad and lasagne!
Adr Bas via google.com - Mar 2, 2020
Ordered lasagna, takes a while but extremely worth the wait. Garlic bread was sensational, and that's an understatement. Prices were beyond reasonable and the staff was engaging and attentive to our group. Others ordered the fish fry and were happy with freshness and portions. Highly recommended.
Chris Jones via google.com - Mar 1, 2020
Came for three buffett. Food was hot and fresh. Service was great. Try adding a dessert of some sorts to the buffet. Most like something sweet after they eat.
ToniAnn Wattawa via google.com - Mar 1, 2020
Good ... read more
Joe Tomter via google.com - Feb 29, 2020
Buffet was small but very good. Pizza, lasagna, and garlic bread were the highlights.
James Nazarovech via google.com - Feb 28, 2020
Good lunch buffet, lots of selection but the quality can be hit or miss depending on the day.
Robert Mochel via google.com - Feb 27, 2020
Pizza is to die for(pep&saus)! The famous garlic butter bread are mouthwatering 🙌🙌🙌😋😋😋😋😋 ... read more
Stephanie Martinez via google.com - Feb 26, 2020
Awesome 👍.🍕 ... read more
Bruno Shaw via google.com - Feb 25, 2020
Mama Mia's is the best Italian in the Milwaukee area. Fun brick-like garlic bread and delicious (and reasonably priced) pizza. Service I thought was a tad slow but that's totally understandable because tasty food takes time. I also thought the ambiance was pleasantly dated and old-fashioned for a classic feel. Mama Mia's is highly re ... read more
Jeffrey Newholm via google.com - Feb 25, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire