skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

The waitress was very understanding with our large group. She was so helpful and kind. The pizza and garlic bread SLAPPED. No complaints :) ... read more
Amanda Pautz via google.com - May 24, 2022
Great food. Great waitress. Nice environment. Loved it .
Tiffany Scardino via google.com - May 22, 2022
Update to 5/18/22 post. I was notified that my purchase had been refunded. While appreciated, it wou
Update to 5/18/22 post. I was notified that my purchase had been refunded. While appreciated, it would have been nice to have received a personal call from the manager. I may give Mama Mia's another chance given their refund response to my disappointing carry-out experience. I will, however, be very careful.
Deborah R. via yelp.com - May 19, 2022
Stoped this afternoon for their famous garlic toast and tried a grilled cheese also. Both were just
Stoped this afternoon for their famous garlic toast and tried a grilled cheese also. Both were just fabulous!
Jim N. via yelp.com - May 19, 2022
I looooove the garlic bread. The italian sausage sandwich is made with the garlic bread.....whaaaaaaat?!!! Pizza is great too. They had a all you can eat lunch years ago. Not sure if they still do.
Juan Cruz via google.com - May 17, 2022
Best food i ever ate.
Stuart Maxel via google.com - May 16, 2022
Garlic bread and food was great... servers telling the host how to no longer seat their sections, not so great. Huzzah ... read more
Andrew Sawyer via google.com - May 16, 2022
What is not to love about this classic gem, in the heart of Stallis? Great service, even if they are a little short handed at times. But, our server was super attentive for a Friday night. Then of course we did there amazing pizzas, super thin crust and full of flavor. Then there's there awesome salad. But, always our favorite the ... read more
Juston Edwards via google.com - May 10, 2022
Awesome pizza and garlic bread. Highly recommend.
MVS Vone via google.com - May 9, 2022
Love this place ... read more
aaron mcclain via google.com - May 3, 2022
Ordered pizza, ravioli and alfredo. All good stuff.
Shannon Kelley via google.com - May 2, 2022
Great Garlic Bread!!!
withakdamit via google.com - Apr 25, 2022
It had been several years since we ate at Momma Mia's, but the food was as good as we remembered it. The waitstaff served us well. The restaurant is currently undergoing some renovation but nothing that dampened our enthusiasm for the meal. Pro tip: the garlic bread is to die for.
James Aderman via google.com - Apr 14, 2022
Classic Italian Fair, very fair price, super tasty and delicious ... read more
David Figon via google.com - Apr 14, 2022
Love this atmosphere!
Here's the deal -- this place makes quality pizza and PHENOMENAL garlic bread. The place is always busy so workers are extremely busy, be patient, the food is worth it. Plus, I love the dining room, it's old school cozy and kind of communal. You absolutely must get the garlic bread, I grew up on this garlic bread, there's nothing lik ... read more
Drew H via tripadvisor.com - Apr 11, 2022
Had lasagna, husband had parmesan chicken, it was really Good but that Tiramisu was the bomb! Great Service!!!
Anna J via google.com - Apr 10, 2022
Lasagna and Garlic Bread was delicious. I think the best time to come there is at Lunch time
Lasagna and Garlic Bread was delicious. I think the best time to come there is at Lunch time ... read more
Ambies Lynn via facebook.com - Apr 4, 2022
Great pizza.
Phyllis and Peter Beaver via google.com - Mar 21, 2022
Garlic bread here is delicious 😋 ... read more
Terri Benner via google.com - Mar 21, 2022
Great food ... read more
Lauren House via google.com - Mar 20, 2022
Awesome food and service!
Tim Lehmann via google.com - Mar 18, 2022
Kaylee was the most gracious host! The food and your prices are within our means. Your Authentic Sauce and the love of Italy can be tasted and appreciated in your sauce.. Your the Best. By all means! Can't wait to go back! Love you! Bon Apitite! 😋 ... read more
Mariann Tomaro via google.com - Mar 8, 2022
Yum ... read more
LAUREN House via google.com - Mar 7, 2022
Best garlic bread in town.
Jeff B via google.com - Mar 6, 2022
The Garlic Bread, lasagna and pizza are a few of the 🏆 winners here. No frills just thin crust pizza. 👍 ... read more
Dennis W via google.com - Feb 20, 2022
Been going there for years. I love this place it's comfort food for me!!!
LCbr1j via google.com - Feb 17, 2022
Excellent food ... read more
Patricia Thomson via google.com - Feb 15, 2022
Short staffed food always goos ... read more
Sue Yourich via google.com - Feb 8, 2022
Super amazing food great service!!
Harvey p via google.com - Jan 31, 2022
As always, amazing Garlic Bread, more fantastic food & wonderful fun service from Jean Pierre (Jerrod), the ORIGINAL MaMa Mia’s, nothing like it!
Glenn Hanson via google.com - Jan 30, 2022
Great meal and great service from our waiter Jean Pierre a.k.a. Jared!
David Lawler via google.com - Jan 30, 2022
Great Italian food, always a good meal !
Chris Schaaf via google.com - Jan 25, 2022
First timer here, I love pizza and pasta and heard all about their famous garlic bread so decided I needed to try this place out. We got cheesy garlic bread, ravioli, and pizza. People weren’t lying, cheesy garlic bread was awesome! The pizza was also really good! It’s a very thin crispy crust. The service was also really good, very ... read more
leah price via google.com - Jan 23, 2022
Had a medium salad and a large pizza. Kelly was our server.She said it would be good. Ordered sausage, mushrooms and onions. She lied.....it was great. We will be back.
Don Cimoch Don cC via google.com - Jan 21, 2022
Gotta get the garlic bread. It's always something you should have at least once.
Jacob S (MiltownRep) via google.com - Jan 21, 2022
Very good ... read more
Bryan Wezyk via google.com - Jan 18, 2022
Great ... read more
Terry Liska via google.com - Jan 17, 2022
We were staying at the Hampton Inn that's just a hop, skip and a jump away and Mama Mia's was recomm
We were staying at the Hampton Inn that's just a hop, skip and a jump away and Mama Mia's was recommended to us by the front desk. It was a cold day. Walking probably wasn't the greatest idea, but it really isn't that far. We got in and immediately got seated and were greeted by Jean Pierre. He's a character so be prepared. We enjoye ... read more
Bruce C. via yelp.com - Jan 17, 2022
on a very very busy Friday night I ordered carry out. While waiting at the carry out window (which i
on a very very busy Friday night I ordered carry out. While waiting at the carry out window (which is separate from the restaurant and keeps carry-out patrons from "clogging" the restaurant waiting area -brilliant) I was able to observe kitchen staff. They were polite, respectful to each other, efficient, and seemed to be enjoying th ... read more
Susan W. via yelp.com - Jan 14, 2022
Good food always reasonably priced also ... read more
Travis Kreuser via google.com - Jan 7, 2022
Beside them fudging the time it will be ready... It was a very good pie the sauce is awesome ... read more
Steve M via google.com - Jan 2, 2022
This is certainly one of the best pizza places in Milwaukee. Great crust, great flavor. Pickup or dine in.
Bob L via google.com - Dec 28, 2021
Ordered carryout lasagna and garlic bread. It was cheesy and delicious. It was more than enough for
Ordered carryout lasagna and garlic bread. It was cheesy and delicious. It was more than enough for my family.
Carol Muellenbach via facebook.com - Dec 28, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire